Monday, April 11, 2011

Reading Response 12: 4/11/11

A Man of Natural Architecture
Frank Lloyd Wright was one of few architects that was more concerned with working side by side with nature rather than beating in into submission.  His work can be divided into several different phases:

  • The time between when he opened his office in 1893 to the building of the Robie House (1908-1910)
  • The Taliesin Phase (1911-1914)
  • The time between the design of the Imperial Hotel to the construction of Fallingwater in 1934 and Taliesin West in 1938
  • The time between the construction of the Johnson Wax Administration Building in 1936 to the building of the Marin County Civic Center in 1957
  • He died in 1959
Frank Lloyd Wright
The buildings he designed include four hundred houses and about a dozen other major buildings.  Wright liked to break away from tradition and create his own personal stylistic development and he was always looking for ways to further abstract his architecture.  One idea that is carried out in all of his residential buildings that we have looked at is that the fireplace/hearth is the heart of the home located at the very center and the rest of the house unfolds from there. 

The Robie House
The house stretches horizontally across the rectangular lot that it is contained in and has several separate horizontal bands that lead your eye across the front of the building.  The walls that run across the front of the house almost make it seem like a guarded fortress but at the same time with the long horizontal bands across the house it reflects the horizontal linearity of the street and the sidewalk running across in front and on one side of it.  He also used different colored mortar in the brick work to make the horizontal lines stand out while the vertical ones seem to melt away into the same color as the bricks to emphasis the horizontal nature of the structure.  Wright purposefully hid the front door in this building so that you would have to walk around the front of the house and experience the architecture before entering the structure.  Every aspect of this house was designed by Wright him self right down the to the carpet and the windows.  The windows of which were artistically designed almost like stained glass so that they would allow for light to enter the space but at the same time allow enough privacy so curtains would be unnecessary.
The Robie House

Robie House Vs. Steiner House
The Robie House designed by Frank Lloyd Wright has many similarities to that of the Steiner House by Adolf Loos.  However, most of these similarities are hiding beneath the blatantly obvious.  Both buildings have an interior that is 
  • intimate
  • richly detailed
  • crafted down to the simplest of details
However, the clear difference between these two buildings is there relationship to the world outside the building.  The Robie House has a lot of porches and platforms extending off front the house where as the Steiner House has all exterior detail stripped away to give a very simple exterior.  

The Robie House
Steiner House

Taliesin East
Wright designed this house after a trip to Italy in 1909.  It was first intended to be a retreat in Spring Green, Wisconsin and then he transformed it into a home instead.  Its name comes from the Book of Taliesin, which is a collection of poems and prophecies attributed to a 6th-century Welsh court poet.  This building represented to drastic changes away from his earlier architecture which had to be built on a certain size lot in a suburban neighborhood and were designed to gradually move from formal spaces to informal spaces within the building.  This house was built on the top of a broad hill and had plenty of space to expand into and lacked this clear division seen in his previous buildings.  Wright designed this building with what he though was a uniquely American receptivity to the landscape around the house.  He said it was not "on" the hill but "of" the hill,  for it was not easy "to tell where pavement and walls left off and ground began," because of gardens with low walls and stone steps leading from them up to the house.  The low horizontal roof reflects the low and slowly rolling hills of the landscape and the rough stone walls that are clearly manufactured seem to still have a natural experience to them.  All of these aspects of having the house be "of" the hill give people inside of the house a sense of being embedded in the landscape.  Wright described this house as a "natural house" in that it is "native in spirit."  This house is a reflection of the things that Wright saw in his visit to Italy, such as the great Renaissance, the Baroque villas, and the gardens.  Taking what he saw in Italy he designed this house to be not only a house but also a country estate, a farm, a studio, a workshop, and a family seat all wrapped up into one.
Taliesin East

Robie House, Taliesin East, and Fallingwater
In looking at all three of these houses Wright designed in all different periods of his career you can still see the underlying themes of what was important to him in his designs that never really changed much but that he expanded upon and worked them further to get exactly the effect he wanted in his buildings.  For example, all three of these structures are focused on a horizontal form, the hearth is the heart of the home at the center, and he found it very important to work along side with nature rather than over powering it.  This idea of working with the natural aspects rather than demolishing them is what I think makes his architecture so enjoyable and interesting.  Fallingwater and Taliesin East represent this idea better because they were not as restricted as the Robie House was in its design but he still worked with that building to make it reflect the landscape around it even though the landscape around it was not as natural.  
The Robie House

Taliesin East
Fallingwater


Information from Ching Textbook
Images from Google Images

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Blog Post 12: 4/11/11

A building/place that I think represents "good design for all" is Numba Parks in Osaka, Japan.  The reason that I think this represents good design for all is because it has so many elements combined into one.  It has an office space for working, a shopping mall for playing, and natural garden areas for just relaxing and enjoying some sun.  If you compare it to the architecture surrounding it it has a much earthier and greener look to it that makes it stand out from everything around it.  The location of this building/place is across the street from a train stop which just happens to be the one right after boarding the train from the airport which means that it is easily accessible for both locals and tourists.  Also, I think this building/place is aesthetically pleasing and is very interesting to look at and I will bet its an even more interesting place to go.



Source: http://www.arch1design.com/NAMBA_PARKS_1.html

Friday, April 8, 2011

Unit Summary 2: 4/8/11

Week 5: Eyes dance across surface, music enfolds, light washes from above.  Worship spaces stand as tangible expressions of faith in glass and stone.

Week 6: The first millennium ends, the modern world map unfolds. We see more enlightened places and people than in previous notions of the "dark age".

Week 7: Making rules to break with gothic ideas and re-link to the ancients of the western world. Observing continuities with the past in the east.

Week 8: As western rules made and written, designers work across genre and scale to bend and break the rules. Eastern designers maintain a continuous approach.

Week 9: Colonial expansion brings ideas and people around the world. In these encounters, emulations and maintaining differences both become important.

Week 10: Architecture and design obscure significant political, social, and cultural change brought by revolution and invention throughout the world.

Building on the past to create a better future
During the fifth week of class we talked about the ideas of expressing of faith through glass and stone and architecture being frozen music.  People of this time expressed their religions by building elaborate places of worship in which to house their religious practices or places that were symbolic of their faith.  For example, the pyramids, the parthenon, the pantheon, the basilica of constantine and this is also still done with churches today.  They also tended to build religious buildings on important religious sites such as the Church of the Holy Sepulchre which marks where Jesus is buried and the Church of the Nativity marks where he was born.  Santa Costanza in Rome marks where Constantine's daughter's burial site.

Evolution of the Early Churches

Then there was the concept of architecture being frozen music and how they both shaped one another.  For example, in this video the although the cathedral shown is not one of the ones we reviewed in class the music being played within its  hall still seems to fit with the architecture around it.
This and many other spaces the music and the architecture seem to reflect one another and fit together as one.

"I call architecture frozen music."
-Joham Wolfgang von Goethe 

"Architecture is music in space, as it were, a frozen music."
-Friedrich von Schelling

In the sixth week of class we discussed the unfolding scenes of world maps.  Every topic that we have studied in this class has been a cognitive map and their under lying ideas have been based on cognitive maps.  These maps talk about the rules and the physical space of the buildings and the architecture.
Circle, Groves, and Stacks

Combination of circle and cross marks
very sacred space

Everything can be a cognitive map and can be interpreted included the spaces and places within architectural buildings.

Then we moved on later in the week to talking about gothic cathedrals which are also planned out using cognitive maps such as:

gothic cathedral layout
The cognitive map in the upper image is demonstrating the purpose of the layout of most gothic cathedrals including this one which is the Cologne Cathedral.

Cologne Cathedral

Cognitive map of planning of
Amiens Labyrinth 

This cognitive map is used in the planning out of the labyrinth of the Amiens Cathedral.  At the very center of this labyrinth is a stone with images honoring the architects and the bishop.

Amiens Labyrinth

These miraculous cathedrals were massive in size with elaborate decoration and ornamentation.  These buildings were intended to show the relationship between man and God by stretching as far skyward as possible without collapse.  Which unfortunately the majority of these gothic cathedrals did collapse because they did not yet have the proper means to create a building of this size and extravagance however the ones still standing today managed to be saved.  With these churches they were trying to create a glass lantern which goes back to the earlier idea of expressing faith through glass and stone which is the two major materials in these cathedrals.

Amiens Cathedral
During the seventh week we talked about the great western and eastern design rule book.  The western world was trying to explain the world around them through use of architecture and taking broad ideas from the past and using them to make new things.  Whereas in the eastern world they tend to build upon the same ideas over and over again and never really change much instead they just replace the things that do not work and stick with the things that do.  Both the eastern and western worlds speak the same design language just in their own unique ways.

In the eight week of class we learned about the rules from the previous week and how designers began to go out of their way to break these rules.  We also talked about how during their breaking of the rules they spared no expense in doing so through either elaborate decorations, extragerating details, they put an emphasis on materials, made elaborate front facade to strut their stuff.  Also, they focused more on spreading out horizontally and controlling the landscape rather than stretching the building vertically.  Some buildings of this time period followed some of the rules while breaking others to make the building stand out from the rest.  
Baroque style
One of these buildings known as the Villa Rotunda designed by Palladio resembled the Pantheon but instead with a porch on each of the four sides of the building which broke the rules of being on axis because the building did not have a specific sense of direction due to the four identical porches that did not specify which way to enter the space.  This building influenced Monticello which we visited on our field trip earlier this week.  With Monticello I think that the back of the building or the garden entrance looks more like it should be the front entrance than the main entrance itself.  Another designed space that influenced Jefferson's work at the University of Virginia is the Piazzo Campidoglio designed by Michelangelo.  In this space there are two buildings angled slightly towards the main building to create emphasis on the central building.  Jefferson uses this in the design of the UVA lawn in front of the library to put emphasis on the large domed library as the most important building.

Piazzo Campidoglio
University of Virginia lawn
Throughout all of the architecture that the have studied water has been a very important element.  From the aqueducts to the detailed decoration in the Baroque time period.  They can all be linked back to an important aspect of water.
Water, water, water

We also discussed how architecture is constantly changing and building on what previous designers have done and improving it based on the past.  We used the nautilus shell to demonstrate this idea of constantly changing and expanding forms of architecture and design.  

Nautilus shell picture with my added information and theories

In week nine we started talking about colonial expansion and how people and ideas started to move all around the world.  The ideas of needing commodity, firmness, and delight in design are still as prevalent in this time period as they were before.  During this time everything was in revolution and being modern became very important.  Then we covered the semiotics and language of design.  The semiotics are the latent meanings in everyday life that need to be uncovered to truly understand the design.  

"There exists a normally hidden set of rules, codes, and conventions through which meanings particular to specific social groups are made universal."
-Ronald Barthes 

Then in the tenth and final week of this unit we talked about the idea of taking matters and turning them over on themselves and the idea of a design cycle.  The design cycle would resemble that of a cartwheel, which Patrick demonstrated in class for us, because it is a continuing loop that in architecture and design that goes from revolution to revolution.  In an ideal world each of these loops and periods are even to one another.  However, in reality they are very different.  We also again looked at the idea of object, space, building, and place which has been an important idea throughout this entire semester and not just this specific unit.  Viewing architecture in this way helps us to look at the connections between all of the aspects of design.  The connections of the object to the space, the space to the building, and the building to the place.  All of these things are interconnected.  We also covered the revolution and how ironically the rules were being followed in the "revolution" whereas they were being broken and stretched in the Baroque time period just before this one.  This causes it hard to identify objects, spaces, and buildings because usually the ones that looked revolutionary actually were not.  Then we finished off the unit with briefly talking about the worlds fairs but there are covered in more detail in the next unit.

So overall we are still dealing with the general overall ideas still being passed down through time.  These ideas include circles, groves, and stacks; the ideas of cognitive maps that can be used to explain architecture; the importance of water; importance of commodity, firmness, and delight; connections between object, space, building, and pace; and the idea of viewing architecture and design as nautilus shell because it is constantly building on pervious ideas from previous time periods but trying to out do them at the same time.  Architecture and design is ever changing and always expanding in its ideas, forms, and underlying concepts to create a spectacular history and an even more extraordinary future.


 Images from Google Images

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Reading Response 11: 4/6/11

Beaux-Arts Style
This style sprouted from the teachings of Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris, France. Buildings created off of the ideas from this school created buildings with grader interiors and a conservative style that were inspired by French Classical Architecture of the 17th and 18th centuries. Such buildings could be recognized based on:
  • elaborate interior decoration
  • grand carvings
  • gilding
  • luxurious marble
  • opulent lighting
All of these details in one created an atmosphere of magnificence inside the buildings in which they were contained such as:
  • large hotels
  • department stores
  • opera houses
  • extravagant houses for the wealthy
One of their own
Jean Louis Charles Garnier, a graduate of the Ecole School, created the most well-known example of this style with his design of the foyer of the Paris Opera. He crated it with a wide sweeping staircase, caryatids, polychrome marble, and gloriously carved ornamentation in an over the top Baroque Style.  The vast number of candelabras in the space magnified the lavish design and quite literally made it dazzling.
Interior
Staircase
Bottom of staircase
 From the front facade of the building it does not seem as though this building holds the wonders that it contains.
View of exterior
Influence on America
Both of these greatly influenced architecture in America.  For example, Richard Morris Hunt was the first American to join the Ecole in 1846.  He graduated and returned in 1855 and upon his return he designed French Renaissance Revival mansions for millionaires such as W.K. Vanderbilt and J.J. Astor. 
W.K. Vanderbilt house designed by Richard Morris Hunt
J.J. Astor house designed by Richard Morris Hunt
More famously he also designed George W. Vanderbilt's house also known as the Biltmore house in Asheville, NC. This building reflects that of the Paris Opera with its relatively simple exterior but then extraordinary interiors within.
External view of Vanderbilt mansion (Biltmore)
Interior
Interior
Interior
Interior

Information from Massey article
Images from Google Images

Blog Post 11: 4/6/11



Modernizing Architecture
The rise of modernism was due to the fact that everyone wanted to out do those before them but then they came up with architecture that was very simple. Architecture that had all of the elaborate detail stripped away but still had its underlying meaning behind it.  
I think it was so important for people by the beginning of the 20th century to be working so hard to be modern because they were working to create something new without having all of that surface detail but still conveying a message through the architecture.


Images from Google Images

Sunday, March 27, 2011

Reading Response 10: 3/28/11

Revolution to Pollution
When the industrial revolution began there we so many factories and such poor working conditions and yet people were so busy going about their own business that they hardly even noticed and the ones that did notice did not seem to care.  The pollution all of these factories were creating was beginning to have global affects in the 19th century.  There were towns such as Manchester, Leeds in England that were filled with basically nothing but factories.  Cities like Manchester were lacking several of that aspects that were common to cities in England in the past such as the city having no:

  • large streets
  • parks
  • churches
  • palaces
  • cultural institutions
  • elegance

Factory based cities like these created and took on a life all their own.  Despite these cities lack of common aspects of cities in England their populations were so high that they were competing in size with grander cities like London and Paris.  Manchester became the second largest city in England behind London.  These industrial cities also lacked any kind of urban planning.  For example, there was no sewages system and even something as simple as water delivery, which is highly important in every city was difficult due to the lack of planning.  Due to all the filth in the city outbreaks of typhoid and tuberculosis were very common.  The cities were severely polluted by:

  • factories
  • sewage
  • waste from slaughter houses
  • other debris
Factory Pollution
The pollution was so bad that the Thames River, which runs through Manchester to London smelled so horrible that work in the Parliament building beside the river in London was usually impossible.  Life in these industrial cities was horrible and the people in them usually did not live very long due to the pollution and dreadful living conditions.  The average life expectancy for people living in these cities was 28 years old. 
Painting of Manchester skyline
Industrial city of Manchester
A Change in the Wind
The problems these cities created were ignored until 1830 and things started to change.  The Great Reform Act of 1832 changed city districts to reflect changes in the pollution.  These changes included:
  • The Factory Acts of the 1830's which reduced the houses of child labor
  • The Mines Act of 1842 which prohibited all women and boys under the age of 10 from working underground
  • The Ten Hours Act of 1847 which limited the workday of women and small children to 10 hours
During the 1860's Joseph Bazalgette designed a series of underground sewerage pipes to move the waste downstream from the city.  Later water and electricity were added into this system.
Factory workers
Industrial Revolution and Architecture
The most important change in the architectural aspect was the creation of the factories themselves.  The ones that made the biggest impact however were the cotton and clothing factories, which had to be positioned near water and run off of waterwheels.  The structures were uniform in appearance and were usually rectangular blocks of undecorated brick or stone with wood flooring and were 4-6 floors tall.  The power of the waterwheel is distributed through the building through a system of shafts, gears, and belts.  This system was later improved with the invention of the wire rope around 1850.  The invention of electric machines also allowed the factories to be built in places other than along side rivers.  
Cotton factory powered by a waterwheel
Lowell, Massachusetts
The town was designed and built by the Merrimack Manufacturing Company.  They borrowed  British technology to create the first successful and completely mechanized cotton mill in the United States.  The plan for the town was very simple.  The  mills were arranged in a row along the canal with their backs to the Merrimack River and the housing for the workers was planned out in a rectangular fashion.  In the town there was a church, library, school, bank, and a mansion for the director of the factory.  Then the main street in town was lined with shops and public buildings.
Lowell, Massachusetts
In Conclusion
Through these changes the factories that we know of today were created.  Due to regulations the factories impact on the environment is controlled.  The advances of technology allow for continuing improvements in the design of the factories and their pollution control.

Images from Google Images
Information from Ching Textbook

Blog Post 10: 3/28/11

An object from the United States that I think carries messages of revolution much like the dollar bill is the U.S. postage stamps.  Unlike the dollar bill, which has stayed consistently the same throughout history since it was first created the postage stamps have changed to represent our changing history.  The stamps have shown images of many different things such as:

  • presidents and other important figures
  • important landmarks 
  • new inventions
  • important events
  • important sayings and quotes
  • other things that represent the U.S. as a country and its history
Past U.S. Stamps







Todays U.S. Postage Stamp


I think that these objects are revolutionary because they show our changing history and everything that that includes whether its changing presidents, advancements in technology, important milestones, or things that represent us as a nation.

Images from Google Images